State Court of Appeals / Ariz. Ct. App.

ChartOne, Inc. v. Bernini

Decided February 6, 2004. Philip G. Espinosa wrote the opinion for the court.

83 P.3d 1103 · Cited 114 times

Official text

We don’t host opinion text or publish a summary of this ruling — read the official public-domain text for the court’s holding and reasoning, and verify against the primary source.

Precedents cited

Decisions in our collection this opinion relies on, ordered by how often it cites each. Cases we publish link through; others open the full text.

Gilmore v. Cohen · 386 P.2d 81
Perkins v. Komarnyckyj · 834 P.2d 1260
Bergeron Ex Rel. Perez v. O'NEIL · 74 P.3d 952
Vega v. Sullivan · 19 P.3d 645
Grant v. Arizona Public Service Co. · 652 P.2d 507
Twin City Fire Insurance v. Burke · 63 P.3d 282
Englert v. Carondelet Health Network · 13 P.3d 763
Styles v. Ceranski · 916 P.2d 1164
State Ex Rel. Pennartz v. Olcavage · 30 P.3d 649
State Ex Rel. Romley v. Fields · 35 P.3d 82
Calmat of Arizona v. State Ex Rel. Miller · 859 P.2d 1323
State v. Just · 675 P.2d 1353
Arizona Independent Redistricting Commission v. Fields · 75 P.3d 1088
State v. Baca · 926 P.2d 528
Thunderbird Metallurgical Inc. v. Arizona Testing Laboratories · 423 P.2d 124
City of Tucson v. Superior Court · 798 P.2d 374
Taylor v. DiRico · 606 P.2d 3
Anderson v. Muniz · 515 P.2d 52
Sedillo v. City of Flagstaff · 737 P.2d 1377
Mendez v. Robertson · 42 P.3d 14
Greenwald v. Ford Motor Co. · 993 P.2d 1087
Martinez v. Schneider Enterprises, Inc. · 873 P.2d 684
Trebesch v. Superior Court · 855 P.2d 798
Phoenix Title & Trust Co. v. State Ex Rel. Herman · 425 P.2d 434
Parrish v. Camphuysen · 488 P.2d 657

Cited by

Later opinions in our collection that cite this decision.

Robinson v. Kay · 236 P.3d 418
Sierra Tucson Crc Health Group v. Louise Litwack · 230 Ariz. 255
Dialog4 System Engineering GmbH v. Circuit Research Labs, Inc. · 622 F. Supp. 2d 814
Grosvenor Holdings, L.C. v. Figueroa · 218 P.3d 1045
Ruesga v. Kindred Nursing Centers West, L.L.C. · 161 P.3d 1253
Steinberger v. McVey · 234 Ariz. 125
Ford v. ChartOne, Inc. · 908 A.2d 72
Potter v. Vanderpool · 240 P.3d 1257
Keg Restaurants Arizona, Inc. v. Jones · 240 Ariz. 64
FIRETRACE USA, LLC v. Jesclard · 800 F. Supp. 2d 1042
Sonoran Desert Investigations, Inc. v. Miller · 141 P.3d 754
State v. Fell · 97 P.3d 902
DIANA H. v. Rubin · 171 P.3d 200
Scott Douglas Nordstrom v. State of Arizona · 213 Ariz. 434
State v. Kelly · 112 P.3d 682
State v. Brown · 115 P.3d 128
Gravel Resources of Arizona v. Hills · 170 P.3d 282
Fisher v. Edgerton · 236 Ariz. 71
Smith v. Mitchell · 214 Ariz. 78
Arizona Department of Economic Security v. Reinstein · 214 Ariz. 209
State Ex Rel. Thomas v. Gordon · 144 P.3d 513
Sierra Tucson, Inc. v. Bergin Ex Rel. County of Pima · 239 Ariz. 507
State v. Campoy · 149 P.3d 756
State ex rel. Montgomery v. Harris · 232 Ariz. 76
Wells Fargo Bank N.A. v. Rogers · 239 Ariz. 106

Explore from here

Philip G. Espinosa’s Judicial Record · Ariz. Ct. App. · How we source opinions

Source: opinion metadata, authorship, and citation counts from the Free Law Project’s CourtListener bulk data (public domain). Data last verified 2026-07-09. Informational only; verify against the primary source before relying. Not a consumer report (FCRA).