Finding

How many senators of the other party voted yes on federal judicial confirmations that drew a “no” vote, by president

Among Senate confirmations of federal judges that drew at least one “no” vote, the median number of “yes” votes from senators of the other party was 20 under George H.W. Bush (3 confirmations) and 3 under Joseph R. Biden (225). In Donald J. Trump’s second term so far it is 0, and 48 of 60 such confirmations (80%) drew no “yes” vote from the other party. Under George H.W. Bush, William J. Clinton and George W. Bush, every such confirmation drew at least one “yes” vote from the other party.

Counted from the Senate’s own senator-by-senator roll calls (through November 20, 2026) and the Federal Judicial Center’s record of Article III judges, as of November 21, 2026, and recounted every week when that record is refreshed. Last updated November 21, 2026.

Companion finding: How many federal judges were confirmed over at least one “no” vote, by president. Both count the same confirmations by the same rules. Also counted from the same confirmations: How old federal judges were when appointed, by president.

Other-party “yes” votes by president

PresidentOther partyOpposedWith roll callMedian yesRangeNoneFive or fewerMajorityIndependents’ yes
George H.W. BushDemocratic332011–4600.0%00.0%133.3%0
William J. ClintonRepublican31301 without408–5400.0%00.0%2066.7%0
George W. BushDemocratic26251 without201–4800.0%520.0%936.0%14
Barack ObamaRepublican1031021 without240–50109.8%2423.5%5352.0%186
Donald J. Trumpfirst term, 2017 to 2021Democratic1821793 without70–474324.0%8748.6%6435.8%83
Joseph R. BidenRepublican2272252 without30–424118.2%15669.3%114.9%545
Donald J. Trumpsecond term, from 2025 (to date)Democratic61601 without00–134880.0%5388.3%00.0%7
Donald J. Trumpboth termsDemocratic2432394 without30–479138.1%14058.6%6426.8%90

Other party: the party opposite the president. Opposed: confirmations with at least one “no” vote (as on the companion finding). With roll call: of those, confirmations whose senator-by-senator roll call is on this site; every figure after this column is over these alone. Median yes: median “yes” votes from the other party’s senators. Range: fewest to most “yes” votes from the other party’s senators. None: no “yes” vote from the other party. Five or fewer: five or fewer “yes” votes from the other party (including none). Majority: “yes” votes from more than half of the other party’s senators. Independents’ yes: “yes” votes by senators recorded as independent, counted on neither side.

Shares are of the confirmations with a roll call, to one decimal place. Every president links to the full list of judges they appointed. Download this table as CSV. The figures and the CSV may be reused, with a link to this page.

Line by line: Download every confirmation counted as CSV. One row for each of the 2,399 Senate confirmations of Article III judges from Jimmy Carter on, with the court, the vote, the judge’s age at confirmation (the confirmation year minus the year of birth) and, where the Senate’s senator-by-senator roll call is on this site, the other party’s “yes” votes and the roll call itself. A blank cell is a value the record does not hold. Every finding is counted from these confirmations by the rules under “How this was counted” on its page. This file may be reused, with a link to this page.

Share of opposed confirmations with no “yes” vote from the other party, by presidentGeorge H.W. Bush: 0.0%; William J. Clinton: 0.0%; George W. Bush: 0.0%; Barack Obama: 9.8%; Donald J. Trump, first term: 24.0%; Joseph R. Biden: 18.2%; Donald J. Trump, second term: 80.0%0%25%50%75%100%George H.W. Bush: 0 of 3 opposed confirmations with a roll call (0.0%) drew no “yes” vote from DemocratsGeorge H.W. Bush0.0%William J. Clinton: 0 of 30 opposed confirmations with a roll call (0.0%) drew no “yes” vote from RepublicansWilliam J. Clinton0.0%George W. Bush: 0 of 25 opposed confirmations with a roll call (0.0%) drew no “yes” vote from DemocratsGeorge W. Bush0.0%Barack Obama: 10 of 102 opposed confirmations with a roll call (9.8%) drew no “yes” vote from RepublicansBarack Obama9.8%Donald J. Trump, first term, 2017 to 2021: 43 of 179 opposed confirmations with a roll call (24.0%) drew no “yes” vote from DemocratsDonald J. Trump, first term24.0%Joseph R. Biden: 41 of 225 opposed confirmations with a roll call (18.2%) drew no “yes” vote from RepublicansJoseph R. Biden18.2%Donald J. Trump, second term, from 2025: 48 of 60 opposed confirmations with a roll call (80.0%) drew no “yes” vote from DemocratsDonald J. Trump, second term (to date)80.0%
Share of each president’s opposed judicial confirmations (at least one “no” vote, with a senator-by-senator roll call) on which no senator of the other party voted yes. Donald J. Trump’s terms are shown one bar each.

How this was counted

Which confirmations
The opposed confirmations of the companion finding: every Senate confirmation of a judge to an Article III court in the Federal Judicial Center’s Biographical Directory of Article III Federal Judges whose roll call drew at least one “no” vote. Both pages are counted by the same code, so each president’s “Opposed” figure here is the one on that page. A voice vote or a unanimous roll call is not an opposed confirmation and is not counted here.
Where coverage starts
The Senate’s online senator-by-senator roll-call record, the source of every vote counted here, begins with the 101st Congress (January 3, 1989). A president is counted only when all of their confirmations fall inside it, so the table starts with George H.W. Bush, the first such president. The companion finding also counts Jimmy Carter (5 opposed confirmations, 0 with a senator-by-senator record here) and Ronald Reagan (6 opposed confirmations, 0 with a senator-by-senator record here); those votes predate the record and are not counted or estimated here.
Coverage
Of the 633 opposed confirmations from George H.W. Bush on, 624 have the Senate’s senator-by-senator roll call on this site (George H.W. Bush: 3 of 3; William J. Clinton: 30 of 31; George W. Bush: 25 of 26; Barack Obama: 102 of 103; Donald J. Trump, first term: 179 of 182; Joseph R. Biden: 225 of 227; Donald J. Trump, second term: 60 of 61). The other 9 have no such record here and are left out of every figure after the “Opposed” column; they are not estimated: Sonia Sotomayor (William J. Clinton, October 2, 1998, 68–28); Priscilla Richman (George W. Bush, May 25, 2005, 56–43); Gregg Jeffrey Costa (Barack Obama, April 26, 2012, 92–2); Danielle Jo Forrest (Donald J. Trump, first term, November 6, 2019, 73–17); Douglas Russell Cole (Donald J. Trump, first term, December 4, 2019, 64–29); Franklin Ulyses Valderrama (Donald J. Trump, first term, September 17, 2020, 68–28); Christine Patricia O'Hearn (Joseph R. Biden, October 19, 2021, 52–44); Arianna Julia Freeman (Joseph R. Biden, September 29, 2022, 50–47); Richard Wesley Bennett (Donald J. Trump, second term, November 20, 2026, 49–43).
The other party
The party opposite the president whose nomination the Senate confirmed: Republican senators under a Democratic president, Democratic senators under a Republican one. Roger L. Gregory, first appointed by William J. Clinton and confirmed on the nomination of George W. Bush, is counted under George W. Bush, as on the companion finding, so the other party on that vote is the Democrats (48 of them voted yes).
Party at the time of the vote
Each senator is counted under the party letter the Senate’s roll call records for that senator on that vote, so a senator who changed party is counted under the party of the day. 7 senators appear under more than one party in the roll calls counted: Ben Campbell (CO), Democratic on votes from 1993 to 1994, Republican on votes from 1997 to 2004; James Jeffords (VT), Republican on votes from 1990 to 2000, independent on votes from 2001 to 2006; Joe Lieberman (CT), Democratic on votes from 1990 to 2006, independent on votes from 2007 to 2012; Joseph Manchin (WV), Democratic on votes from 2010 to 2024, independent on votes in 2024; Richard Shelby (AL), Democratic on votes from 1990 to 1994, Republican on votes from 1997 to 2022; Kyrsten Sinema (AZ), Democratic on votes from 2019 to 2022, independent on votes from 2023 to 2024; Arlen Specter (PA), Republican on votes from 1990 to 2008, Democratic on votes from 2009 to 2010.
Independents
The roll call records an independent senator as an independent; it does not record which party, if either, the senator sat with. So a senator recorded as independent is counted on neither side, and their “yes” votes are shown in a column of their own: 835 “yes” votes on 423 opposed confirmations, cast by James Jeffords, Angus King, Joe Lieberman, Joseph Manchin, Bernard Sanders and Kyrsten Sinema. The majority test likewise counts only the other party’s own senators. Counting every independent with the Democrats instead would change only these figures: George W. Bush: confirmations with a majority would be 10, not 9; Donald J. Trump’s second term: confirmations with none would be 47, not 48, confirmations with five or fewer would be 52, not 53; Donald J. Trump, both terms: confirmations with none would be 90, not 91, confirmations with five or fewer would be 139, not 140. Under a Democratic president the other party is the Republicans, so that change would move no figure there.
Not voting and “present”
Only a “yea” is a “yes” vote. A senator recorded as “Not Voting” or “Present” is not counted as voting yes, and still counts as one of the other party’s senators for the majority test. Across the 624 confirmations counted, the other party’s senators were recorded 1,797 times as not voting and 0 times as present.
Majority
“Yes” votes from more than half of the other party’s senators on that roll call. The roll call lists every sitting senator, voting or not, so that is more than half of the other party’s senators then serving. Counted against only the other party’s senators who voted yes or no, the figure would be 55, not 53, for Barack Obama, 66, not 64, for Donald J. Trump’s first term and 66, not 64, for Donald J. Trump, both terms; every other row is the same either way.
Tie votes
The Vice President is not a senator and is not on the roll call, so a tie-breaking vote is never counted as a “yes” from either party. 4 confirmations counted here were decided by the Vice President after the senators tied; the examples below give the senators’ own tally.
Several nominees, one vote
One roll call confirmed several nominees together (5 confirmations in all). As on the companion finding, such a roll call counts once for each nominee it confirmed, with the same votes for each.
A judge confirmed twice
As on the companion finding, a confirmation is one Senate vote on one nomination: a judge confirmed more than once is counted once for each confirmation, and a judge confirmed to one seat shared by two or three districts is counted once.
Two terms
Donald J. Trump’s two terms are shown one row each, divided by confirmation date at the start of the later term (January 20, 2025), and combined in the row that follows them. The second term is still in progress; its row counts confirmations through November 20, 2026.
Tallies
For every one of the 624 confirmations counted, the senators’ “yea” and “nay” votes on the roll call add up to the tally in the FJC’s record (less the Vice President’s vote where one broke a tie).

The most and the fewest other-party “yes” votes

For each president: the three opposed confirmations with the most “yes” votes from the other party’s senators, and the three with the fewest. Ties go to the earlier confirmation; a president with six or fewer has all of them shown, most first. “Other party” gives that party’s “yes” votes and its senators on the roll call; “Vote” is the senators’ whole tally and links to the Senate’s roll call.

George H.W. Bushother party: Democrats

ExampleJudgeCourtConfirmedOther partyVote
All 3David Hackett SouterSupreme Court of the United StatesOctober 2, 199046 of 5590–9
Edward Earl CarnesEleventh CircuitSeptember 9, 199220 of 5662–36
Clarence ThomasSupreme Court of the United StatesOctober 15, 199111 of 5752–48

William J. Clintonother party: Republicans

ExampleJudgeCourtConfirmedOther partyVote
MostRonald Lee GilmanSixth CircuitNovember 6, 199754 of 5598–1
Brian Theadore StewartDistrict of UtahOctober 5, 199954 of 5593–5
Janet C. HallDistrict of ConnecticutSeptember 11, 199753 of 5598–1
FewestRosemary BarkettEleventh CircuitApril 14, 19948 of 4461–37
H. Lee SarokinThird CircuitOctober 4, 199414 of 4463–35
Susan Oki MollwayDistrict of HawaiiJune 22, 199814 of 5556–34

George W. Bushother party: Democrats

ExampleJudgeCourtConfirmedOther partyVote
MostRoger L. GregoryFourth CircuitJuly 20, 200148 of 5093–1
Raymond W. GruenderEighth CircuitMay 20, 200446 of 4897–1
Roger T. BenitezSouthern District of CaliforniaJune 17, 200446 of 4898–1
FewestJanice Rogers BrownDistrict of Columbia CircuitJune 8, 20051 of 4456–43
Jeffrey S. SuttonSixth CircuitApril 29, 20032 of 4852–41
William Holcombe Pryor Jr.Eleventh CircuitJune 9, 20052 of 4453–45

Barack Obamaother party: Republicans

ExampleJudgeCourtConfirmedOther partyVote
MostAnn Marie DonnellyEastern District of New YorkOctober 20, 201550 of 5495–2
LaShann Moutique DeArcy HallEastern District of New YorkNovember 16, 201548 of 5493–1
Brian R. MartinottiDistrict of New JerseyJuly 6, 201647 of 5492–5
FewestJohn James McConnell Jr.District of Rhode IslandMay 4, 20110 of 4650–44
Alison Julie NathanSouthern District of New YorkOctober 13, 20110 of 4748–44
Cornelia Thayer Livingston PillardDistrict of Columbia CircuitDecember 12, 20130 of 4551–44

Donald J. Trump, first term, 2017 to 2021other party: Democrats

ExampleJudgeCourtConfirmedOther partyVote
MostMark Jeremy BennettNinth CircuitJuly 10, 201847 of 4772–27
Claria Horn BoomEastern District of Kentucky and Western District of KentuckyApril 10, 201845 of 4796–1
Ralph R. EricksonEighth CircuitSeptember 28, 201744 of 4695–1
FewestAmul Roger ThaparSixth CircuitMay 25, 20170 of 4652–44
John Kenneth BushSixth CircuitJuly 20, 20170 of 4651–47
Leonard Steven GraszEighth CircuitDecember 12, 20170 of 4650–48

Joseph R. Bidenother party: Republicans

ExampleJudgeCourtConfirmedOther partyVote
MostCamela Catherine TheelerDistrict of South DakotaMay 16, 202442 of 4990–4
Gretchen Suzanne LundNorthern District of IndianaJanuary 25, 202439 of 4987–6
Leon SchydlowerWestern District of TexasMarch 22, 202439 of 4990–8
FewestEunice Cheryl LeeSecond CircuitAugust 7, 20210 of 5050–47
Myrna PérezSecond CircuitOctober 25, 20210 of 5048–43
Lucy Haeran KohNinth CircuitDecember 13, 20210 of 5050–45

Donald J. Trump, second term, from 2025other party: Democrats

ExampleJudgeCourtConfirmedOther partyVote
MostHarold Dean Mooty IIINorthern District of AlabamaOctober 21, 202513 of 4566–32
Susan Courtwright RodriguezWestern District of North CarolinaDecember 4, 202510 of 4557–32
Michael Craig MartinEastern District of MichiganJuly 22, 202610 of 4562–36
FewestWhitney Downs HermandorferSixth CircuitJuly 14, 20250 of 4546–42
Cristian Matthew StevensEastern District of MissouriJuly 22, 20250 of 4550–47
Joshua Michael DivineEastern District of Missouri and Western District of MissouriJuly 22, 20250 of 4551–46

Related

Sources

Last updated November 21, 2026 (the FJC record’s date). Verify against the primary source before relying.