Finding

How many federal judges were confirmed over at least one “no” vote, by president

Under Jimmy Carter, 5 of 261 (1.9%) Senate confirmations of federal judges drew at least one “no” vote. Under Joseph R. Biden, 227 of 235 (96.6%) did, and in Donald J. Trump’s second term so far, 57 of 57 (100%). The share first passed one in ten under Barack Obama (31.3%) and first passed half in Donald J. Trump’s first term (77.8%).

Counted from the Federal Judicial Center’s record of Article III judges, as of November 16, 2026, and recounted every week when that record is refreshed. Last updated November 16, 2026.

Confirmations by president

PresidentShare opposedOpposedConfirmedUnanimousVoiceShare voiceNot recordedMedian noMedian days
Jimmy Carter1.9%5261025698.1%02159
Ronald Reagan1.6%6383437397.4%040.537
George H.W. Bush1.6%3193019098.4%03686
William J. Clinton8.2%313771832887.0%01199
George W. Bush8.0%2632616613441.1%028.5121
Barack Obama31.3%10332912010632.2%019164
Donald J. Trumpfirst term, 2017 to 202177.8%182234173515.0%035150.5
Joseph R. Biden96.6%227235262.6%043104
Donald J. Trumpsecond term, from 2025 (to date)100.0%5757000.0%04578
Donald J. Trumpboth terms82.1%239291173512.0%041128

Share opposed: opposed, as a share of confirmations. Opposed: roll calls with at least one “no” vote. Confirmed: Senate confirmations counted. Unanimous: roll calls with no “no” votes. Voice: voice votes (no tally recorded). Share voice: voice votes, as a share of confirmations. Not recorded: no vote method recorded. Median no: median “no” votes among the opposed confirmations. Median days: median days from nomination to confirmation.

Shares are of each president’s confirmations counted, to one decimal place. Every president links to the full list of judges they appointed. Download this table as CSV. The figures and the CSV may be reused, with a link to this page.

Share of confirmations with at least one “no” vote, by presidentJimmy Carter: 1.9%; Ronald Reagan: 1.6%; George H.W. Bush: 1.6%; William J. Clinton: 8.2%; George W. Bush: 8.0%; Barack Obama: 31.3%; Donald J. Trump, first term: 77.8%; Joseph R. Biden: 96.6%; Donald J. Trump, second term: 100.0%0%25%50%75%100%Jimmy Carter: 5 of 261 confirmations (1.9%) drew at least one “no” voteJimmy Carter1.9%Ronald Reagan: 6 of 383 confirmations (1.6%) drew at least one “no” voteRonald Reagan1.6%George H.W. Bush: 3 of 193 confirmations (1.6%) drew at least one “no” voteGeorge H.W. Bush1.6%William J. Clinton: 31 of 377 confirmations (8.2%) drew at least one “no” voteWilliam J. Clinton8.2%George W. Bush: 26 of 326 confirmations (8.0%) drew at least one “no” voteGeorge W. Bush8.0%Barack Obama: 103 of 329 confirmations (31.3%) drew at least one “no” voteBarack Obama31.3%Donald J. Trump, first term, 2017 to 2021: 182 of 234 confirmations (77.8%) drew at least one “no” voteDonald J. Trump, first term77.8%Joseph R. Biden: 227 of 235 confirmations (96.6%) drew at least one “no” voteJoseph R. Biden96.6%Donald J. Trump, second term, from 2025: 57 of 57 confirmations (100.0%) drew at least one “no” voteDonald J. Trump, second term (to date)100.0%
Share of each president’s Article III judicial confirmations that drew at least one “no” vote in the Senate. Donald J. Trump’s terms are shown one bar each.

How this was counted

Which confirmations
Every Senate confirmation of a judge to an Article III court (the Supreme Court, the courts of appeals, the district courts and the specialized Article III courts such as the Court of International Trade) in the Federal Judicial Center’s Biographical Directory of Article III Federal Judges, for nominations by Jimmy Carter and every later president: 2,395 in all. Bankruptcy, magistrate, territorial and other fixed-term judges are not in that record and are not counted.
A judge confirmed twice
A confirmation is one Senate vote on one nomination. A judge confirmed more than once (a district judge later confirmed to a court of appeals, for example) is counted once for each confirmation: 126 judges account for 254 of the 2,395. A judge confirmed to one seat shared by two or three districts appears in the FJC’s record once per district; that is one nomination and one vote, so it is counted once (18 judges, 22 additional district entries).
Which president
Each confirmation is counted under the president whose nomination the Senate confirmed. That is the appointing president in every case but one: Roger L. Gregory, first appointed by William J. Clinton and confirmed on the nomination of George W. Bush (the FJC’s “reappointing president”), is counted under George W. Bush. Not counted: 2 appointments the Senate never confirmed (Charles Willis Pickering Sr., Walter Meheula Heen).
At least one “no”
A roll call with one or more “no” votes. A roll call with no “no” votes is not counted as opposed; it is shown as a unanimous roll call (327 of the 967 roll calls). The median “no” votes is taken over the opposed confirmations only.
Voice votes
The FJC records two ways the Senate confirmed: a roll call vote, with its tally, or a voice vote. It does not record unanimous consent separately, so a confirmation without a recorded tally is counted here as the FJC records it, as a voice vote. A voice vote leaves no tally, so whether any senator voted no cannot be read from the record: voice votes are a group of their own, counted neither as opposed nor as unanimous.
Vote method not recorded
A confirmation with no vote type, a vote type of “Unknown”, or a roll call with no tally is shown in its own column and counted on neither side. Every confirmation on this page has its method recorded.
Days to confirmation
The days from the nomination date to the confirmation date in the FJC’s record, using only dates the record gives to the day (every confirmation on this page has both). The FJC’s nomination date is the nomination the Senate confirmed: when a nomination was returned to the President and submitted again, the count starts at the later nomination, so it can be shorter than a nominee’s whole wait.
Two terms
Donald J. Trump’s two terms are shown one row each, divided by confirmation date at the start of the later term (January 20, 2025), and combined in the row that follows them. The second term is still in progress; its row counts confirmations through November 12, 2026.
Tallies
Every tally is the FJC’s. For 935 of the 967 roll calls the Senate’s own roll-call record is also on this site, and the number of “no” votes in the two agrees in every one. In 4, the senators tied and the Vice President’s vote decided; the FJC counts that vote among the ayes, and the examples below give the senators’ own tally. One roll call confirmed several nominees together (5 confirmations in all); the “no” votes on such a roll call count for each nominee it confirmed.

The closest and most lopsided opposed confirmations

For each president since William J. Clinton: the three opposed confirmations with the lowest share of senators voting to confirm, and the three with the highest share that still drew at least one “no”. Ties go to the earlier confirmation. A judge’s page has the full record of each vote.

William J. Clinton

ExampleJudgeCourtConfirmedVote
ClosestWilliam A. FletcherNinth CircuitOctober 8, 199857–41
Richard A. PaezNinth CircuitMarch 9, 200059–39
Susan Oki MollwayDistrict of HawaiiJune 22, 199856–34
Most lopsidedJanet C. HallDistrict of ConnecticutSeptember 11, 199798–1
Ronald Lee GilmanSixth CircuitNovember 6, 199798–1
G. Patrick MurphySouthern District of IllinoisApril 2, 199898–1

George W. Bush

ExampleJudgeCourtConfirmedVote
ClosestJames Leon HolmesEastern District of ArkansasJuly 6, 200451–46
William Holcombe Pryor Jr.Eleventh CircuitJune 9, 200553–45
Dennis W. SheddFourth CircuitNovember 19, 200255–44
Most lopsidedRoger T. BenitezSouthern District of CaliforniaJune 17, 200498–1
Raymond W. GruenderEighth CircuitMay 20, 200497–1
Steven M. CollotonEighth CircuitSeptember 4, 200394–1

Barack Obama

ExampleJudgeCourtConfirmedVote
ClosestVictor Allen BoldenDistrict of ConnecticutNovember 20, 201449–46
Alison Julie NathanSouthern District of New YorkOctober 13, 201148–44
John James McConnell Jr.District of Rhode IslandMay 4, 201150–44
Most lopsidedNancy Dell FreudenthalDistrict of WyomingMay 5, 201096–1
Susie MorganEastern District of LouisianaMarch 28, 201296–1
James Alan SotoDistrict of ArizonaMay 15, 201493–1

Donald J. Trump, first term, 2017 to 2021

ExampleJudgeCourtConfirmedVote
ClosestJonathan Allen KobesEighth CircuitDecember 11, 201850–50tie broken by the Vice President
Andrew Stephen OldhamFifth CircuitJuly 18, 201850–49
Katherine Amber CrytzerEastern District of TennesseeDecember 16, 202048–47
Most lopsidedClaria Horn BoomEastern District of Kentucky and Western District of KentuckyApril 10, 201896–1
Ralph R. EricksonEighth CircuitSeptember 28, 201795–1
Steven Charles SeegerNorthern District of IllinoisSeptember 11, 201990–1

Joseph R. Biden

ExampleJudgeCourtConfirmedVote
ClosestLoren Linn AliKhanDistrict of ColumbiaDecember 5, 202350–50tie broken by the Vice President
Araceli Martinez-OlguinNorthern District of CaliforniaFebruary 28, 202348–48tie broken by the Vice President
Margaret Rose GuzmanDistrict of MassachusettsMarch 1, 202348–48tie broken by the Vice President
Most lopsidedCamela Catherine TheelerDistrict of South DakotaMay 16, 202490–4
Gretchen Suzanne LundNorthern District of IndianaJanuary 25, 202487–6
Ernest GonzalezWestern District of TexasMarch 22, 202488–7

Donald J. Trump, second term, from 2025

ExampleJudgeCourtConfirmedVote
ClosestEmil Joseph Bove IIIThird CircuitJuly 29, 202550–49
Daniel Mack TraynorEighth CircuitJuly 23, 202648–47
Andrew Bray DavisWestern District of TexasApril 20, 202647–46
Most lopsidedHarold Dean Mooty IIINorthern District of AlabamaOctober 21, 202566–32
Gregory Carl CookNorthern District of AlabamaNovember 12, 202649–27
Susan Courtwright RodriguezWestern District of North CarolinaDecember 4, 202557–32

Related rankings

Sources

Last updated November 16, 2026 (the FJC record’s date). Verify against the primary source before relying.