| Adalberto Jose Jordan | Eleventh Circuit | Barack Obama | 2012 | Against |
| Brian Curtis Wimes | Eastern District of Missouri | Barack Obama | 2012 | Not voting |
| Cathy Ann Bencivengo | Southern District of California | Barack Obama | 2012 | Against |
| David Ogden Nuffer | District of Utah | Barack Obama | 2012 | Against |
| Gershwin Allen Drain | Eastern District of Michigan | Barack Obama | 2012 | Against |
| Gina Marie Groh | Northern District of West Virginia | Barack Obama | 2012 | Against |
| Jacqueline Hong-Ngoc Nguyen | Ninth Circuit | Barack Obama | 2012 | Not voting |
| Jeffrey James Helmick | Northern District of Ohio | Barack Obama | 2012 | Against |
| Jesse Matthew Furman | Southern District of New York | Barack Obama | 2012 | Against |
| John Edward Dowdell | Northern District of Oklahoma | Barack Obama | 2012 | Confirm |
| John Joseph Tharp Jr. | Northern District of Illinois | Barack Obama | 2012 | Not voting |
| John Melvin Gerrard | District of Nebraska | Barack Obama | 2012 | Against |
| John Thomas Fowlkes Jr. | Western District of Tennessee | Barack Obama | 2012 | Against |
| Kevin McNulty | District of New Jersey | Barack Obama | 2012 | Against |
| Lorna Gail Schofield | Southern District of New York | Barack Obama | 2012 | Confirm |
| Margo Kitsy Brodie | Eastern District of New York | Barack Obama | 2012 | Against |
| Mark Eaton Walker | Northern District of Florida | Barack Obama | 2012 | Not voting |
| Mary Elizabeth Phillips | Western District of Missouri | Barack Obama | 2012 | Against |
| Mary Geiger Lewis | District of South Carolina | Barack Obama | 2012 | Against |
| Michael Andre Shipp | District of New Jersey | Barack Obama | 2012 | Not voting |
| Michael P. Shea | District of Connecticut | Barack Obama | 2012 | Not voting |
| Michael Walter Fitzgerald | Central District of California | Barack Obama | 2012 | Against |
| Miranda Mai Du | District of Nevada | Barack Obama | 2012 | Against |
| Paul Jeffrey Watford | Ninth Circuit | Barack Obama | 2012 | Not voting |
| Paul William Grimm | District of Maryland | Barack Obama | 2012 | Confirm |
| Robin Stacie Rosenbaum | Southern District of Florida | Barack Obama | 2012 | Against |
| Ronnie Abrams | Southern District of New York | Barack Obama | 2012 | Against |
| Stephanie Dawn Thacker | Fourth Circuit | Barack Obama | 2012 | Against |
| Stephanie Marie Rose | Southern District of Iowa | Barack Obama | 2012 | Against |
| Susie Morgan | Eastern District of Louisiana | Barack Obama | 2012 | Against |
| Thomas Owen Rice | Eastern District of Washington | Barack Obama | 2012 | Against |
| Timothy Spafard Hillman | District of Massachusetts | Barack Obama | 2012 | Not voting |
| Alison Julie Nathan | Southern District of New York | Barack Obama | 2011 | Against |
| Amy Berman Jackson | District of Columbia | Barack Obama | 2011 | Confirm |
| Anthony Joseph Battaglia | Southern District of California | Barack Obama | 2011 | Confirm |
| Arenda Lauretta Wright Allen | Eastern District of Virginia | Barack Obama | 2011 | Confirm |
| Bernice Bouie Donald | Sixth Circuit | Barack Obama | 2011 | Against |
| Cathy Bissoon | Western District of Pennsylvania | Barack Obama | 2011 | Not voting |
| Christopher Fitzgerald Droney | Second Circuit | Barack Obama | 2011 | Not voting |
| Claire Claudia Cecchi | District of New Jersey | Barack Obama | 2011 | Confirm |
| Diana Saldaña | Southern District of Texas | Barack Obama | 2011 | Confirm |
| Edgardo Ramos | Southern District of New York | Barack Obama | 2011 | Not voting |
| Edward John Davila | Northern District of California | Barack Obama | 2011 | Not voting |
| Edward Milton Chen | Northern District of California | Barack Obama | 2011 | Against |
| Evan Jonathan Wallach | Federal Circuit | Barack Obama | 2011 | Confirm |
| Henry Franklin Floyd | Fourth Circuit | Barack Obama | 2011 | Confirm |
| James Edward Shadid | Central District of Illinois | Barack Obama | 2011 | Not voting |
| James Emanuel Boasberg | District of Columbia | Barack Obama | 2011 | Confirm |
| James Paul Oetken | Southern District of New York | Barack Obama | 2011 | Against |
| Jane Margaret Triche Milazzo | Eastern District of Louisiana | Barack Obama | 2011 | Confirm |
| Jimmie V. Reyna | Federal Circuit | Barack Obama | 2011 | Not voting |
| John Arnold Kronstadt | Central District of California | Barack Obama | 2011 | Confirm |
| John James McConnell Jr. | District of Rhode Island | Barack Obama | 2011 | Against |
| Kevin Hunter Sharp | Middle District of Tennessee | Barack Obama | 2011 | Confirm |
| Mae Avila D'Agostino | Northern District of New York | Barack Obama | 2011 | Confirm |
| Max Oliver Cogburn Jr. | Western District of North Carolina | Barack Obama | 2011 | Confirm |
| Michael Francis Urbanski | Western District of Virginia | Barack Obama | 2011 | Confirm |
| Michael H. Simon | District of Oregon | Barack Obama | 2011 | Against |
| Morgan Christen | Ninth Circuit | Barack Obama | 2011 | Against |
| Paul Adam Engelmayer | Southern District of New York | Barack Obama | 2011 | Confirm |
| Paul Kinloch Holmes III | Western District of Arkansas | Barack Obama | 2011 | Confirm |
| Robert David Mariani | Middle District of Pennsylvania | Barack Obama | 2011 | Against |
| Scott Wesley Skavdahl | District of Wyoming | Barack Obama | 2011 | Confirm |
| Sharon Louise Gleason | District of Alaska | Barack Obama | 2011 | Against |
| Stephen Andrew Higginson | Fifth Circuit | Barack Obama | 2011 | Not voting |
| Steve CarMichael Jones | Northern District of Georgia | Barack Obama | 2011 | Confirm |
| Susan Laura Carney | Second Circuit | Barack Obama | 2011 | Against |
| Susan Owens Hickey | Western District of Arkansas | Barack Obama | 2011 | Against |
| Timothy Martin Cain | District of South Carolina | Barack Obama | 2011 | Confirm |
| Yvonne Gonzalez Rogers | Northern District of California | Barack Obama | 2011 | Against |
| Audrey Goldstein Fleissig | Eastern District of Missouri | Barack Obama | 2010 | Not voting |
| Barbara Milano Keenan | Fourth Circuit | Barack Obama | 2010 | Confirm |
| Benita Yalonda Pearson | Northern District of Ohio | Barack Obama | 2010 | Against |
| Brian Anthony Jackson | Middle District of Louisiana | Barack Obama | 2010 | Confirm |
| Denny Chin | Second Circuit | Barack Obama | 2010 | Not voting |
| Elena Kagan | Supreme Court | Barack Obama | 2010 | Against |
| Ellen Lipton Hollander | District of Maryland | Barack Obama | 2010 | Confirm |
| Gary Feinerman | Northern District of Illinois | Barack Obama | 2010 | Confirm |
| Gloria Maria Navarro | District of Nevada | Barack Obama | 2010 | Confirm |
| Jane Branstetter Stranch | Sixth Circuit | Barack Obama | 2010 | Against |
| Joseph A. Greenaway Jr. | Third Circuit | Barack Obama | 2010 | Not voting |
| Lucy Haeran Koh | Northern District of California | Barack Obama | 2010 | Not voting |
| Marc Thomas Treadwell | Middle District of Georgia | Barack Obama | 2010 | Confirm |
| Mark Allan Goldsmith | Eastern District of Michigan | Barack Obama | 2010 | Confirm |
| Nancy Dell Freudenthal | District of Wyoming | Barack Obama | 2010 | Confirm |
| Ojetta Rogeriee Thompson | First Circuit | Barack Obama | 2010 | Confirm |
| Raymond Joseph Lohier Jr. | Second Circuit | Barack Obama | 2010 | Not voting |
| Rosanna Malouf Peterson | Eastern District of Washington | Barack Obama | 2010 | Confirm |
| Sharon Johnson Coleman | Northern District of Illinois | Barack Obama | 2010 | Confirm |
| Tanya Walton Pratt | Southern District of Indiana | Barack Obama | 2010 | Confirm |
| Thomas Ignatius Vanaskie | Third Circuit | Barack Obama | 2010 | Against |
| William Joseph Martinez | District of Colorado | Barack Obama | 2010 | Against |
| William Martin Conley | Western District of Wisconsin | Barack Obama | 2010 | Confirm |
| Andre Maurice Davis | Fourth Circuit | Barack Obama | 2009 | Against |
| Charlene Vanessa Edwards Honeywell | Middle District of Florida | Barack Obama | 2009 | Confirm |
| David Frank Hamilton | Seventh Circuit | Barack Obama | 2009 | Against |
| Gerard E. Lynch | Second Circuit | Barack Obama | 2009 | Confirm |
| Irene Cornelia Berger | Southern District of West Virginia | Barack Obama | 2009 | Not voting |
| Jacqueline Hong-Ngoc Nguyen | Central District of California | Barack Obama | 2009 | Confirm |
| Jeffrey Lynn Viken | District of South Dakota | Barack Obama | 2009 | Confirm |
| Roberto Antonio Lange | District of South Dakota | Barack Obama | 2009 | Confirm |
| Sonia Sotomayor | Supreme Court | Barack Obama | 2009 | Against |
| Brian Stacy Miller | Eastern District of Arkansas | George W. Bush | 2008 | Confirm |
| G. Steven Agee | Fourth Circuit | George W. Bush | 2008 | Confirm |
| Helene N. White | Sixth Circuit | George W. Bush | 2008 | Against |
| Mark Steven Davis | Eastern District of Virginia | George W. Bush | 2008 | Confirm |
| William T. Lawrence | Southern District of Indiana | George W. Bush | 2008 | Confirm |
| Benjamin Hale Settle | Western District of Washington | George W. Bush | 2007 | Confirm |
| Debra Ann Livingston | Second Circuit | George W. Bush | 2007 | Confirm |
| Frederick J. Kapala | Northern District of Illinois | George W. Bush | 2007 | Confirm |
| George H. Wu | Central District of California | George W. Bush | 2007 | Confirm |
| Gregory Kent Frizzell | Northern District of Oklahoma | George W. Bush | 2007 | Confirm |
| Halil Suleyman Ozerden | Southern District of Mississippi | George W. Bush | 2007 | Confirm |
| Janet T. Neff | Western District of Michigan | George W. Bush | 2007 | Confirm |
| Janis Lynn Sammartino | Southern District of California | George W. Bush | 2007 | Confirm |
| John Alfred Jarvey | Southern District of Iowa | George W. Bush | 2007 | Confirm |
| John Daniel Tinder | Seventh Circuit | George W. Bush | 2007 | Confirm |
| Leslie Southwick | Fifth Circuit | George W. Bush | 2007 | Confirm |
| Liam O'Grady | Eastern District of Virginia | George W. Bush | 2007 | Confirm |
| Lisa Godbey Wood | Southern District of Georgia | George W. Bush | 2007 | Confirm |
| Marcia Morales Howard | Middle District of Florida | George W. Bush | 2007 | Confirm |
| Nora Barry Fischer | Western District of Pennsylvania | George W. Bush | 2007 | Confirm |
| Norman Randy Smith | Ninth Circuit | George W. Bush | 2007 | Confirm |
| Philip S. Gutierrez | Central District of California | George W. Bush | 2007 | Confirm |
| Richard Joseph Sullivan | Southern District of New York | George W. Bush | 2007 | Confirm |
| Robert Michael Dow Jr. | Northern District of Illinois | George W. Bush | 2007 | Confirm |
| Thomas Michael Hardiman | Third Circuit | George W. Bush | 2007 | Confirm |
| Timothy D. DeGiusti | Western District of Oklahoma | George W. Bush | 2007 | Confirm |
| Andrew J. Guilford | Central District of California | George W. Bush | 2006 | Confirm |
| Brett M. Kavanaugh | District of Columbia Circuit | George W. Bush | 2006 | Confirm |
| Brian Mark Cogan | Eastern District of New York | George W. Bush | 2006 | Confirm |
| Francisco Augusto Besosa | District of Puerto Rico | George W. Bush | 2006 | Confirm |
| Gray Hampton Miller | Southern District of Texas | George W. Bush | 2006 | Confirm |
| Jack Zouhary | Northern District of Ohio | George W. Bush | 2006 | Confirm |
| Jerome A. Holmes | Tenth Circuit | George W. Bush | 2006 | Confirm |
| Kent A. Jordan | Third Circuit | George W. Bush | 2006 | Confirm |
| Kimberly Ann Moore | Federal Circuit | George W. Bush | 2006 | Confirm |
| Leo Maury Gordon | U.S. Court of International Trade | George W. Bush | 2006 | Confirm |
| Michael A. Chagares | Third Circuit | George W. Bush | 2006 | Confirm |
| Michael Ryan Barrett | Southern District of Ohio | George W. Bush | 2006 | Confirm |
| Milan Dale Smith Jr. | Ninth Circuit | George W. Bush | 2006 | Confirm |
| Noel Lawrence Hillman | District of New Jersey | George W. Bush | 2006 | Confirm |
| Peter G. Sheridan | District of New Jersey | George W. Bush | 2006 | Confirm |
| Renée Marie Bumb | District of New Jersey | George W. Bush | 2006 | Confirm |
| Samuel A. Alito Jr. | Supreme Court | George W. Bush | 2006 | Confirm |
| Sandra Segal Ikuta | Ninth Circuit | George W. Bush | 2006 | Not voting |
| Thomas E. Johnston | Southern District of West Virginia | George W. Bush | 2006 | Confirm |
| Thomas M. Golden | Eastern District of Pennsylvania | George W. Bush | 2006 | Confirm |
| Timothy C. Batten Sr. | Northern District of Georgia | George W. Bush | 2006 | Confirm |
| Brian Edward Sandoval | District of Nevada | George W. Bush | 2005 | Confirm |
| David William McKeague | Sixth Circuit | George W. Bush | 2005 | Confirm |
| Harry Sandlin Mattice Jr. | Eastern District of Tennessee | George W. Bush | 2005 | Confirm |
| Janice Rogers Brown | District of Columbia Circuit | George W. Bush | 2005 | Confirm |
| John Glover Roberts Jr. | Supreme Court | George W. Bush | 2005 | Confirm |
| John Michael Seabright | District of Hawaii | George W. Bush | 2005 | Confirm |
| John Richard Smoak Jr. | Northern District of Florida | George W. Bush | 2005 | Confirm |
| Paul Austin Crotty | Southern District of New York | George W. Bush | 2005 | Confirm |
| Richard Allen Griffin | Sixth Circuit | George W. Bush | 2005 | Confirm |
| Susan Bieke Neilson | Sixth Circuit | George W. Bush | 2005 | Confirm |
| Thomas Beall Griffith | District of Columbia Circuit | George W. Bush | 2005 | Confirm |
| William Holcombe Pryor Jr. | Eleventh Circuit | George W. Bush | 2005 | Confirm |